In a society increasingly shaped by religious and political divisions, relationships are sometimes measured by how much people agree. This tendency appears especially evident in conversations surrounding Israel, where political positions can overshadow relationships between Jews and Christians. Although Christianity and Judaism maintain significant theological differences, those differences need not prevent mutual understanding. Rather, they invite consideration of how conviction, historical awareness, and friendship might coexist.
Recent conflicts in the Middle East have made these relationships more difficult to navigate. Disagreement over governmental decisions can sometimes become confused with attitudes toward Jewish people themselves. Such confusion raises questions extending beyond political support or theological interpretation. Perhaps the challenge for Christian leaders is not simply to explain their convictions, but to consider how those convictions shape relationships with Jewish neighbors.i
Religious disagreement does not automatically produce hostility, but misunderstanding may grow when communities rarely engage one another. Within churches, biblical passages can sometimes be explained without sufficient attention to how Jewish people are portrayed. Even unintended generalizations may encourage listeners to view an entire community through a narrow set of assumptions. Responsible biblical teaching therefore requires attention to both the meaning of Scripture and the impressions its interpretation may leave.ii
The account of the Good Samaritan in Luke 10:25–37 offers a useful pastoral perspective. Jesus describes compassion crossing a boundary marked by historical tension between Jews and Samaritans. The story is not a direct description of modern Jewish-Christian relations, and its original setting should be respected. Nevertheless, it may encourage believers to recognize that concern for others should not depend upon shared religious identity.
History demonstrates why such care matters. Jewish communities endured discrimination, expulsions, and violence in various European societies where Christianity held considerable influence. These developments arose from overlapping religious, political, and economic conditions, yet anti-Jewish interpretations of Scripture also contributed to harmful attitudes. Acknowledging this history, however, does not imply equal responsibility among Christian traditions or individual believers.iii
Some interpretations of Gospel accounts have portrayed Jewish groups as though they represented a single hostile community. Such readings can overlook differences among Jewish people in the first century and the contexts of the biblical narratives. When repeated without explanation, they may reinforce assumptions extending beyond the church service. Pastoral education should therefore combine faithfulness to Scripture with historical care and sensitivity to the people being discussed.iv
Tolerance may establish a foundation for peaceful coexistence, but it does not necessarily create friendship. In this context, tolerance means respecting another person’s dignity and freedom to hold and practice religious beliefs that differ from one’s own, without requiring theological agreement. It does not mean abandoning one’s convictions or treating all religious claims as equally true. People can respect one another’s freedom of belief while remaining unfamiliar with each other’s experiences. Genuine Jewish-Christian engagement requires more than avoiding hostility. It involves the willingness to listen, learn, and build relationships extending beyond a single public event.
Prayer gatherings, educational conferences, and visits to Israel can serve valuable purposes. Yet public expressions of solidarity do not automatically lead to personal understanding of Jewish life. Conversations with rabbis, shared community projects, and opportunities to hear Jewish perspectives may deepen understanding. Such encounters are most meaningful when participants treat each other as neighbors rather than representatives of a political position.v
Some evangelical Christians may wonder whether friendship requires compromising beliefs about Jesus, Scripture, or salvation. These theological differences are substantial and should be discussed with honesty. Nevertheless, respect for another person’s dignity does not require agreement with every conviction a person holds. Genuine friendship may allow both communities to speak truthfully without making theological conformity a condition of relationship.
James 1:19 encourages believers to be quick to listen and slow to speak. Although the passage does not specifically address interreligious dialogue, its counsel is relevant to difficult conversations. Listening involves seeking to understand another person’s experiences rather than merely preparing a response. Such humility may strengthen trust without weakening Christian conviction.
Contemporary discussions of Israel require similar care. Jewish people differ in religious practice, cultural background, and political perspectives, including their opinions of Israeli governmental decisions. Criticism of a government’s policies should not be transferred to Jewish individuals or institutions as collective blame. Likewise, genuine concern for Jewish safety need not prevent thoughtful attention to the suffering of others affected by conflict.vi
Pastors help shape how congregations respond to these complexities. Romans 12:18 encourages believers, as far as it depends on them, to live at peace with others. This instruction does not remove theological disagreement, but it challenges the assumption that disagreement must result in distance or hostility. Christian education may be measured partly by whether it develops discernment alongside knowledge.
Jewish-Christian friendship is therefore more than an expression of tolerance or political solidarity. It calls for historical honesty, careful biblical teaching, and relationships grounded in mutual dignity. Although friendship cannot resolve every theological or political disagreement, it may create space for trust where suspicion previously existed. Perhaps one meaningful measure of Christian leadership is not only the convictions it communicates, but also the relationships those convictions encourage.
i P. Colwell, “Looking Eastwards: Jewish-Christian Relations and the Implications of the Abraham Accords and the Israel-Gaza War,” The Ecumenical Review 77, no. 3–4 (2025): 266–277, https://doi.org/10.1111/erev.70020.
ii C. Setzer, “Antisemitism, Anti-Judaism, and Biblical Interpretation,” Interpretation: A Journal of Bible and Theology 79, no. 3 (2025): 234–243, https://doi.org/10.1177/00209643251328629.
iii Setzer, “Antisemitism, Anti-Judaism, and Biblical Interpretation.”
iv A. Conway-Jones, “Matthew’s Gospel and Jewish-Christian Relations,” The Expository Times 134, no. 10 (2023), https://doi.org/10.1177/00145246231156834.
v N. J. Duff, “Christians Preparing for Conversation: Jewish-Christian Relations,” Theology Today 74, no. 3 (2017): 243–251, https://doi.org/10.1177/0040573617721914.
vi Colwell, “Looking Eastwards.”
Discover The Israel Christian Nexus
See how pastors and faith leaders have taken the first step toward Israel through the Nexus.

